Post by leah on Dec 15, 2012 3:11:42 GMT -5
This is the thread where I'll put all of my out-of-character thoughts and junk.
So, let's see, thoughts on this challenge.
Well, looks like we have at least two liars in our midst. One of them is me, because, let's face it, 29?? I'm telling people that I'm 27, and even then it totally sounds like BS. In fact, I'm apologizing for how stupid I feel for saying 27, because I totally look younger than that. Ahaahhaa.
The other one is Ellen. Here's a hint, galpal. If you've already said in the chat that you're 39, maybe don't go around telling everybody that you're 45 afterwards.
Either she lied then, or she's lying now, and I have no idea which. I think it's more likely that she lied now, but who knows? She's an alternate, so my guess is that she's a veteran. She's certainly clever enough to be a good liar, so I wouldn't put anything past her at this point.
Unfortunately for her, she's a liar who decided to lie to someone with a nigh-on photographic memory, so that's gonna get her kicked outta here sooner rather than later.
Also, Dominic and Liam are both claiming to be construction workers. I told both of them that the other one was claiming that, then decided to suggest to both of them that the host had probably put two of the same thing in the game to make us mistrust each other. This might actually be true, but I was actually pulling a Solomon Gambit*, because I wanted to see how quickly they'd jump on that excuse. Liam was pretty quick to agree that that was totally the reason, while Dominic was like, "Well, that sucks for me, then."
*A Solomon Gambit is when you have two people, one of whom is obviously lying, and you give them a statement which they will respond to differently according to whether or not they're lying. In the original Biblical example, two people both claimed to be the mother of the same baby. Solomon told them to split the baby in half. One mother was cool with it, the other freaked out. Obviously the freakout one was the actual mother, so Solomon gave it to her. So, in my example, Liam was willing to accept the first excuse I offered him, to get the heat off his back. That means that it's much more likely that he's lying to me. Dominic didn't really care about protesting his innocence as much, which means that he's either a fantastic liar or he's actually telling the truth.
I also have data from Colleen and Yuri, so that brings my total up to six, and I should have more coming in from Carly and Leo tomorrow.
Liam is 23, construction worker, black russian, and Slumdog Millionaire
Yuri is 31, motivational speaker, Yuengling, and Speed.
Chase is 28, gym teacher, whiskey sour, Dark Night.
Still need to get: Austin, Leo
EDIT: Nvm just got all this from Liam. I'm going to have to double-check it for validity myself, just to be on the safe side, but it certainly makes my life easier.
AJ 24 Graduate Student Pinot Grigio The Princess Bride
Carly 26 Dance Instructor Texas Margarita 13 Going on 30
Jonah 30 Computer Engineer Blue Moon Goodfellas
Kendell 32 Legal Writer Brooklyn Lager Moonstruck
Ryan 27 Freelance Journalist Screwdriver The Italian Job
Sawyer 25 Store Manager White Russian Dances With Wolves
Tina 22 Waitress Highball The Hills Have Eyes
Paige 20 College Student Sangria Babel
Ben 29 Actuary Makers Mark Memento
So, let's see, thoughts on this challenge.
Well, looks like we have at least two liars in our midst. One of them is me, because, let's face it, 29?? I'm telling people that I'm 27, and even then it totally sounds like BS. In fact, I'm apologizing for how stupid I feel for saying 27, because I totally look younger than that. Ahaahhaa.
The other one is Ellen. Here's a hint, galpal. If you've already said in the chat that you're 39, maybe don't go around telling everybody that you're 45 afterwards.
Either she lied then, or she's lying now, and I have no idea which. I think it's more likely that she lied now, but who knows? She's an alternate, so my guess is that she's a veteran. She's certainly clever enough to be a good liar, so I wouldn't put anything past her at this point.
Unfortunately for her, she's a liar who decided to lie to someone with a nigh-on photographic memory, so that's gonna get her kicked outta here sooner rather than later.
Also, Dominic and Liam are both claiming to be construction workers. I told both of them that the other one was claiming that, then decided to suggest to both of them that the host had probably put two of the same thing in the game to make us mistrust each other. This might actually be true, but I was actually pulling a Solomon Gambit*, because I wanted to see how quickly they'd jump on that excuse. Liam was pretty quick to agree that that was totally the reason, while Dominic was like, "Well, that sucks for me, then."
*A Solomon Gambit is when you have two people, one of whom is obviously lying, and you give them a statement which they will respond to differently according to whether or not they're lying. In the original Biblical example, two people both claimed to be the mother of the same baby. Solomon told them to split the baby in half. One mother was cool with it, the other freaked out. Obviously the freakout one was the actual mother, so Solomon gave it to her. So, in my example, Liam was willing to accept the first excuse I offered him, to get the heat off his back. That means that it's much more likely that he's lying to me. Dominic didn't really care about protesting his innocence as much, which means that he's either a fantastic liar or he's actually telling the truth.
I also have data from Colleen and Yuri, so that brings my total up to six, and I should have more coming in from Carly and Leo tomorrow.
Liam is 23, construction worker, black russian, and Slumdog Millionaire
Yuri is 31, motivational speaker, Yuengling, and Speed.
Chase is 28, gym teacher, whiskey sour, Dark Night.
Still need to get: Austin, Leo
EDIT: Nvm just got all this from Liam. I'm going to have to double-check it for validity myself, just to be on the safe side, but it certainly makes my life easier.
AJ 24 Graduate Student Pinot Grigio The Princess Bride
Carly 26 Dance Instructor Texas Margarita 13 Going on 30
Jonah 30 Computer Engineer Blue Moon Goodfellas
Kendell 32 Legal Writer Brooklyn Lager Moonstruck
Ryan 27 Freelance Journalist Screwdriver The Italian Job
Sawyer 25 Store Manager White Russian Dances With Wolves
Tina 22 Waitress Highball The Hills Have Eyes
Paige 20 College Student Sangria Babel
Ben 29 Actuary Makers Mark Memento